His second lie is told to back up his first lie: the fairy asks him where he lost his gold pieces, and he has to provide an explanation (Walter Scott’s familiar “Oh what a tangled web we weave / When first we practise to deceive!”). He tells the first lie because he’s worried about losing his three remaining gold pieces.
#PINOCCHIO STORY PDF SERIES#
The series of lies Pinocchio tells is instructive. So many of the stories we tell our children are of this kind-Santa Claus is the obvious example-and we should ask ourselves, as parents and also as lovers: How many stories might my child, or my boyfriend, or my partner, or my mom be telling me, not in order to mislead me but rather to tell me something that, if said outright, might be misunderstood or cause me harm? So, for example, if Geppetto told Pinocchio, “I sold my coat in order to buy you a schoolbook,” he would be speaking the literal truth, but his meaning might well be (or be understood by Pinocchio as) “Look what sacrifices I make for you!” By telling Pinocchio that he sold his coat because it was too hot-a lie-he communicates to Pinocchio something like “My coat doesn’t really matter to me, and your schoolbook does, and I don’t want you to feel bad about the fact that I sold my coat.” This is a very nice example of what Bonhoeffer means by the living truth, the more important meanings in communication that may not, and sometimes cannot, be conveyed by strict reportage. But we also often make statements that are not literally true-that are in fact literal lies-while conveying a deeper truth that an honest statement of the facts could not communicate. Of course we often tell a straightforward lie, and for morally blameworthy reasons. Bonhoeffer argues that it is naive and misleading, perhaps even dangerous to suppose that the literal truth always or even typically conveys what we mean when we talk about telling the truth. When the fox and the cat come along, he is easily led into temptation.īecause Geppetto’s lie is such a common one, before we continue Pinocchio’s story, it is worth bringing to mind Dietrich Bonhoeffer’s notion of the living truth.
The first real lie in the story is not told by Pinocchio, who does, however, repeat various fanciful inaccuracies almost as soon as he can speak, but by Geppetto, who sells his coat in order to buy Pinocchio a schoolbook and lies to the boy, telling him that he sold it “Because I found it too hot.” (This is a classic example of a paternalistic lie told with good intentions, of which both a Buddhist and perhaps even Plato would have approved.) Interestingly, Pinocchio understands what his maker has really done, “and unable to restrain the impulse of his good heart he sprang up, and throwing his arms around Geppetto’s neck he began kissing him again and again.” So Pinocchio does have a good heart and a subtle enough intelligence to understand that though Geppetto has lied to Pinocchio, he has done so out of kindness it’s simply that Pinocchio likes to misbehave, and he hasn’t learned the ways of the world yet.
To tell you in confidence, I have no wish to learn it is much more amusing to run after butterflies, or to climb trees and to take young birds out of their nests.” Contra Rousseau, Collodi thinks that a young boy who does not undergo a traditional education will get only naughtier and will “grow up a perfect donkey” (as the cricket warns-and prophesizes-Pinocchio does indeed later become a donkey). When the wise hundred-year-old cricket asks Pinocchio why he wants to run away from home, Pinocchio tells him: “I shall be sent to school and shall be made to study either by love or by force. Collodi seems to have had Rousseau in mind. He behaves, in short, like a fairly typical two-year-old when the two-year-old is misbehaving. In fact he’s badly behaved even before he’s created: while still a stick of wood, he starts a fight between Geppetto and his owner, and once he is a marionette he immediately wreaks all kinds of havoc: he insults Geppetto as soon as he has a mouth, laughs at him, runs away from him, etc.
#PINOCCHIO STORY PDF MOVIE#
When I was a boy I was made distinctly uncomfortable by, and even tried not to think about, the Walt Disney movie “Pinocchio.”īut in Carlo Collodi’s “The Adventures of Pinocchio” (serialized in 1881-1883)-the original text for the Walt Disney adaptation-Pinocchio, unlike Rousseau’s ideal of the child, is created naughty. This piece is drawn from “Love and Lies: An Essay on Truthfulness, Deceit, and the Growth and Care of Erotic Love,” out from FSG on February 3rd.
0 kommentar(er)
